Transfer money from China to USA options?

Home Forums Transfer money from China to USA options?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 38 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5496
    Anonymous
    Guest

    /profile/35-lucylez/?do=hovercard” data-mentionid=”35″ href=”<___base_url___>/profile/35-lucylez/” rel=””>@LucyLez Wow, still only Bank of China and ICBC? I thought the other banks would have caught up by now since they have branches in New York and certainly have the means to offer Direct Drafts drawn in US dollars.

    /profile/37-girlatwork/?do=hovercard” data-mentionid=”37″ href=”<___base_url___>/profile/37-girlatwork/” rel=””>@GirlatWork You actually need 500,000 RMB to maintain a HSBC premier account without monthly fees.

    Maybe I’m wrong, my understanding was that there are no restrictions with ICBC and Bank of China issuing foreign currency bank drafts if you supply them with the foreign currency. I have a long trusted “huang niu” for such matters. There are additional forms to fill out if you (local or foreigner) are buying a value over $10,000. Anyway, the lack of a measly daily limit, low fees, and the ability to Remote Deposit Capture makes it much more efficient than wiring.

    #5497
    Anonymous
    Guest

    China Merchants Bank does not have any retail banking operations in New York or elsewhere in the United States nor are they licensed for such. What they do have is a single branch in NY licensed as a wholesale bank. As a result, it would be impossible for them to transact retail clearing operations via FedWire.

    The same applies for China Construction Bank. It is not authorized to conduct retail banking operations in the United States.

    One nifty feature of HSBC Premier is that if you have status in one HSBC entity, that allows you status in every HSBC entity without having to meet minimum balance requirements in that entity. I opened an HSBC Premier account back when the minimum balance to avoid fees in the US was $50,000. I then used that to obtain status in China with an account that rarely sees more than a few thousand RMB in it.

    There are restrictions.

    Unless, for the most part, you are converting RMB earned from lawful employment into US$ and have supporting documentation, an expat is limited to $500 per day in foreign currency purchase. Those people Chinese regulations consider as domestic individuals are limited to $50,000 per year. Exchanging US$ for RMB is capped for all at $50,000 per year.

    The idea of being able to us US$ cash one already possesses to circumvent restrictions may seem doable, but it is not. First, there is a restriction on foreign remittances for everybody but those who are remitting earnings and have the appropriate documentation. The limit otherwise is $50,000 per year.

    There are other problems with using US$ cash in your possession. First, is the additional fee involved. There are two kinds of US$ in China. There is US$ cash (chao : 钞) and there is US$ forex (hui : 汇) and they are not the same. Only forex can be remitted abroad. If you have cash, it must be first exchanged into RMB and then back to forex before it can be used to buy a demand draft or any other type of remittance. So, if you have, for example, $100,000 in cash and you need a demand draft, you need to “sell” the cash and then “buy” forex. However, there is a $50,000 limit on how much US$ can be converted into RMB each year.

    Even if you have only $50,000 in cash, this would be a stupid way to remit money abroad instead of using RMB directly to buy forex. I’m certain some Einstein will come along and challenge the idea that the cash is sold to buy RMB and then further the RMB is converted into forex. However, they would be wrong. While you may not see or be aware of any “sale” or “purchase,” they do occur. It occurs behind the scene in the State Administration of Foreign Exchange database which must in realtime any foreign currency transaction in any Chinese bank, and it occurs in the fee you will be charged.

    Fee? Yes. An amount in RMB equivalent to the spread the bank would have earned from physically exchanging your US$ cash into RMB and the resulting RMB then further converted back into US$ forex will be tacked onto the cost of the remittance or demand draft.

    So, unless you have no other way to buy the US$ you will need to remit abroad, using your “huang niu” means you are getting FITA for an extra 2% above and beyond the initial 1% spread you pay between the buy and sell rate.

    I have sent wires and also bought demand drafts for over $10,000 and have never had to fill out any additional forms.

    #5498
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Do these demand drafts ever trigger IRS audits? And if so what is the max amount recommended to send per annum to avoid such audits? I have about 40k USD in RMB that I want sent to a checking account to pay for one of my US credit cards, suggestions?

    #5499
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Transactions $10,000 or more per day trigger an automatic currency transaction report (CTR) to the Treasury Department FinCEN that the IRS has access to. Keeping the amounts below that figure and staggering payments will keep you under the radar.

    However, don’t do anything stupid like conducting transactions of $9,990 today and $9,990 tomorrow. Also crazy would be $500 today and $500 tomorrow. Keep transactions well under $10,000 and make them very infrequently — such as two or three times per month. Or even less.

    #5500
    Anonymous
    Guest

    The bank definitely mentioned some additional form that needed to be filed for amounts over $10,000 but it may be that the bank files it with the relevant Chinese agency on your behalf. Or, maybe they were just coming up with some arbitrary hoop to jump through, like the banks here like to do.

    #5501
    Anonymous
    Guest

    The minimum amount to have a HSBC Premier account vary from country to country. One can use the lower amount to meet the requirement, if the required amount is lowery in your home country than RMB 500k as it’s in China. And it doesn’t need to be in form of deposit. It can be any banking products / stocks with HSBC investment account.

    #5502
    Anonymous
    Guest

    USAA was the first bank to allow customers to deposit checks by taking a photo of it with their smartphones. Unfortunately, USAA checking accounts are not available to the general public.

    The minimum for a HSBC Premier account in the US has been $100,000 for quite some time now, I don’t think the required total relationship balance gets that much lower than that in any country; in Malaysia the minimum is RM 200,000.

    #5503
    Anonymous
    Guest

    USAA developed remote capture deposit.

    True, they do have a restricted membership base. But from time to time they do let the general population in and allow them to open general, basic accounts like savings, checking and credit cards.

    #5504
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I send money back home every month. For every $1000 USD, you pay $25 on Western Union. You can send the money to a bank account, if you want, or cash-at-the-window (or cash on delivery, in some countries).

    I’ve been doing this for the last 4 years. Zero hassle.

    To exchange/transfer more than 500 USD in a Bank you need a bunch of papers, just as someone said above, but for WU, all you need is to bring your own USD.

    #5505
    Anonymous
    Guest

    I stopped by a big ICBC on a Sunday to buy a demand draft. The fee was 30 rmb for about 30,000 rmb. Of course, you lose a little money in the currency exchange as well, but overall, not too bad. However, I was told to come pick it up in 5 business days which I wasn’t expecting, but should’ve figured since something like getting a replacement ATM card takes 5-7 days.

    #5506
    Anonymous
    Guest

    The exchange rate is the same as when you buy US$ cash.

    If you go to the main branch for your district, they do it immediately. Smaller branches have to send it to the main branch for signature. There are two signatures if the amount is over a certain amount — $1,000 I think. Branch managers don’t have authority to sign over a certain amount themselves so they send it to the main branch for second signature.

    #5507
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Yes, I’m aware the exchange rate is the same as when buying USD.

    Went to ICBC’s main branch in Jing’an today and inquired about how long it would take for the Demand Draft. They told me 5 days. Afterward, went to a small Bank of China sub-branch across the street from my apt and asked them how long it would take to issue one, they said if I purchase today (Saturday) or tomorrow I could pick it up on Monday. They also mentioned having a Bank of China account is required to purchase one.

    #5508
    Anonymous
    Guest

    With ICBC they have to send everything to main Shanghai HQ to issue draft.

    With Bank of China there is usually one branch in each district which can issue the draft on the spot. I’ve never been required to have a BOC account, but each area might have slight variations.

    Also, I know that in Beijing they will not issue a draft on weekend. I don’t think it’s system issue more than a signature issue. Only certain people can sign the draft if amounts are over $1,000. Maybe those people don’t work on weekends.

    #5509
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Would it be possible to have a foreign draft made at China Construction Bank?

    Or can you do one without having an account at ICBC?

    I’m trying to find the best route to send money back home but I’m not sure USAA will accept the foreign draft through the deposit moblie. I know for sure they can take a travelers check but I’m not sure what the cost on that are and if I need an account with another chinese bank to do it. I just got a China Consruction account two days ago.

    Any other suggestions are welcomed!

    #5510
    Anonymous
    Guest

    As far as I know, you can only buy the Demand Draft at Bank of China or ICBC. You may be able to do it at ICBC without an account. I found that at Bank of China, the procedure was much more tedious and the transaction took at least three times as long as at ICBC, though you are able to retrieve it same day or next as opposed to ICBC’s 5 working days. The two Bank of China locations I have purchased from did require you have an account with them, but this may vary from branch to branch.

    I don’t see why USAA would not accept Demand Drafts via mobile deposit, and if you read further back in this thread, it seems Lucylez has experience doing so. The draft is essentially a check drawn on a foreign bank, that is, if you buy one in China for USD it will be drawn on an affiliate US Bank that is a member of the Federal Reserve. So it is not a “foreign” monetary instrument. To simplify, the Demand Draft I purchased from Bank of China in Shanghai is issued in US dollars to be drawn at Bank of China in New York, NY. If I remember correctly, the Drawee Bank for one I purchased at ICBC was Bank of America. So, it’s US $ from a US Bank.

    I have not had a problem depositing Demand Drafts via Mobile Deposit. My only issue is that the banks I hold accounts with in the US have low daily/monthly limits for mobile deposits. HSBC only recently launched this service for their personal banking customers. Daily limit is $3,000, monthly limit is $5,000. Their app sucks though and takes like 30 min to load on my ipad.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 38 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Our case studies

Featured case studies

guardian
wired
forbes